Life in the
time of James II
by Trisha Hughes
The jury is still out on
James. Was he an egotistical bigot and a tyrant who rode roughshod over the
will of the vast majority of his subjects? Was he simply naïve? Was he perhaps
just plain stupid? Perhaps he was only doing what he thought was best and he
was actually an intelligent, clear-thinking strategically motivated monarch? No
one will ever know the truth.
After his brother’s death,
James ascended the throne with the announcement that he would not be vindictive
or arbitrary. He would be fair, he would not push Catholicism on the country
and he would make no changes to the ministry. Everything looked rosy. No one
had any idea that in three years, he would be fleeing for his life across the
channel to his cousin Louis in France.
It all started just four
months in to his reign in the early days of July when a mysterious ship
appeared off the coast of Dorset. Aboard was the young, ambitious Duke of
Monmouth, Charles II’s illegitimate son, ready to take on his uncle and remove
him from the throne. With him was a small arsenal of weapons, 82 companions and
in his pocket was £230.
Duke of Monmouth by Willem Wissing |
Now we all know Charles II had his shortcomings. Heaven knows he had proved time and again that he was no angel. In his fifteen years on the throne, he was always in conflict with someone. First the Dutch, then the Spanish, and always with Parliament. He was constantly in need of money and there was a long line of women queuing up outside his bedchamber with their hands out for money. Most times, he did whatever he had to do to get it, whether it was the right way or the wrong way.
But for all his blunders
there was always one thing he was consistent in: his belief in the Divine Right
of Kings. And that was the one point that let Monmouth down. You see, Monmouth
was illegitimate.
At the time of Charles’
death, Monmouth was living it up, dancing and enjoying life with a mistress in
Holland, waiting to step back into the limelight in England at the right
moment. Looking at the mess his father had made of things, it was no wonder the
Duke of Monmouth was feeling exasperated. In history, it had taken a lot less
than this to infuriate ambitious relatives to make them finally take a stand.
His landing at Lyme Regis had
been chosen carefully and when he stepped ashore, most of the 3,000 residents
cheered. He stepped off the boat and like many usurpers before him; he kissed
the ground before marching joyously into the town. Inside those pretty country
cottages, a blood lust was brewing against the hated Catholic king.
It only took three days for
the locals to flock to him, more than ready to join his army and fight. The 82
men soon grew to 1500.
James was in the first glow
of a successful Parliament when a messenger arrived at full gallop at Whitehall
with news that Monmouth was proclaiming James a usurper who had murdered his
brother in order to get to the throne. The messenger handed James a letter
stating that 1500 men had signed up to join his army and James was to stand
down. Immediately.
The numbers on both sides
were incredible. By then, Monmouth’s army had swollen to around 7,000 passionate
men following behind him. As for James, he had the backing of every regiment
Parliament could put together and thousands of troops from royal supporters and
earls. As promised, even his son-in-law William of Orange sent three regiments
of infantry to help as well.
William of Orange |
To say William had an
ulterior motive goes without saying. On one hand, if James lost, there would be
a young, arrogant, Protestant king on the throne who would be easy to remove at
a later date. But if Monmouth lost, William planned to take the throne from
James anyway. England did owe him money after all and he had the rabbit
in the hat with his Protestant wife, James’ eldest daughter Mary, by his side.
Either way, he came out a winner.
With his mind fixed on the
big prize, William settled back patiently and waited.
As Monmouth’s army resolutely
marched south, dark thunderclouds started to mass in the sky above them. By the
time his army had reached Somerset, the heavens had opened up and it was
bucketing down. The men who had been filled with confidence only hours before
were soon a miserable dripping group, up to their ankles in mud and soaked
through by the downpour. Still they continued.
James and Monmouth’s armies finally
met near Bridgwater in Somerset three weeks later. But by then, Monmouth’s men
were thoroughly exhausted and thousands had already deserted him. Along the
way, their patriotism had dwindled and the enormity of what they were about to
do suddenly hit them.
Perhaps they’d had a glimpse
of the future because this last battle of the Monmouth Rebellion, named the
Battle of Sedgemoor, was the climax of one of the bloodiest events in English
history as the beautiful Somerset countryside was soaked with the blood of
thousands of men.
Battle of Sedgemoor memorial |
Needless to say, Monmouth’s men were slaughtered and when news came of the victory, James sent supporters out to Bridgwater to bring Monmouth back to London. He had plans for Monmouth and he could barely wait to see the young man crushed before him.
James waited for days. When
his men finally arrived back empty handed, it was with news that Monmouth had
escaped the battle field, disguised as a peasant hoping to hightail it to the
nearest port and escape back to the continent. James desperately sent every
available man out to scour the southeast looking for him and two days later,
only a couple of hours from reaching the coast, Monmouth was arrested, lying
asleep in a ditch.
James must have been
anticipating the moment when Monmouth was finally brought before him. He would
have lived and relived the moment in his head, memorising what he would say and
predicting Monmouth’s total submission. By the time he was told Monmouth was in
the castle, he could barely contain himself. But when he finally set sight on
the young man, he couldn’t believe his eyes. Standing in front of him, beaten
and humiliated, was someone he barely recognised. Only a couple of years ago,
Monmouth had been a dapper young man full of life and vitality with the world
at his feet. The man standing before him was thin, unshaven and shabbily
dressed, begging and sobbing, for mercy. James had to look hard beneath the filth
to see the face of his frightened nephew.
Perhaps most of us would have
remembered the child, not the adult. We would have remembered the laughter and
the playful romps of a cherished tiny boy without a care in the world. Perhaps
we would have been lenient.
James was not that person. He
resolutely sent Monmouth to the Tower of London, his fate sealed. He was
charged and convicted of high treason and sentenced to death by beheading.
It was all done in somewhat
of a rush. From capture to death, barely five days had passed. The night before
his execution, Monmouth would have heard the crowds gathering beyond the tower
walls and he would have known what was happening. The execution of a royal duke
was a massive event. People would be getting up early to get a good seat on the
wooden stands and with food and drinks available, it had the makings of being a
great family day outing.
After Monmouth’s execution, James’
revenge was methodical and meticulous. Monmouth’s men were ruthlessly hunted
down and in the end, the punishments rivalled anything the Tudors had ever done.
In just four weeks, England had lost the best part of a generation.
It was a colossal mistake on
James’ part to execute Monmouth. He would have been much better off showing
leniency by simply keeping him locked away in the Tower indefinitely. The
result of Monmouth’s death was that the Whigs gained strength and popularity
and ultimately, it was the Whigs who were responsible for overthrowing James
later on.
That’s when James made his
fateful mistake. Flush with success, he walked into a meeting in the House of
Lords and informed them that instead of disbanding his army, he would be
keeping it operational.
Warning bells must have been
clanging madly in their heads. Not only was keeping an army active an expense
they could not afford, but it was against every tradition they held. You just
did not keep an army active during peacetime – unless you had an ulterior
motive in mind, that is. The thought had barely taken shape when James told
them he would be making his Catholic friend Richard Talbot, the Lord Deputy in
Ireland his viceroy. That’s when they knew they were in trouble.
By then, James was on a roll
and nothing was going to stand in his way, much less a bunch of pompous nobles
who thought he would do what they told him to do. Their objections fell on deaf
ears and arguments became more heated until James did what every member of his
family had done before him. He dissolved Parliament.
In hindsight, this was
probably the worst thing he could have done. English people still had memories
of Charles I doing the exact same thing after he couldn’t get his own way.
Cromwell had stepped into the picture and things had gone from bad to worse.
They had seen Charles II dissolve Parliament on many occasions but they had
grudgingly forgiven him because life had become a bit more tolerable after the
Cromwell debacle. But this was something else entirely. Their worst nightmare
was becoming a reality as Catholic after Catholic stepped into prominent
positions of power and judges in the Common law courts were dismissed.
Things seemed like they
couldn’t get any worse for England. Until James’ Italian wife gave birth to a healthy
baby boy two years later and they knew their nightmare was only just beginning.
This new birth opened up the possibility of a permanent Catholic dynasty.
It was the final straw. They
wanted James out and the most likely candidate was James’ eldest daughter Mary,
married to William of Orange.
Mary II ~ Portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller |
It was all working out
exactly as William had planned.
Parliament didn’t have to ask
him twice. Unbeknownst to the English, William had already begun assembling an
army. It was perfect timing really. France was occupied with campaigns in both
Germany and Italy, which meant it would be impossible for Louis to drop
everything and rush to James’ aid and with nobody available to try and stop
him, William fully intended to take advantage of the situation. They actually
hadn’t needed to ask him at all.
By November, James finally
realised what was happening but by then it was way too late. As expected, his first
thought was to ask his cousin Louis for help but Louis was already overextended
with problems of his own in Germany. As James received the refusal for help
from Louis, William was already landing in Brixham, in southeast England, with
an army of 11,000 foot soldiers and 4,000 cavalry.
In reality, James’ army
should have been adequate to keep the invaders out. He had the numbers and he
had the advantage of the home ground. What he didn’t have was support from his
most trusted officers. Officer after officer left James’ side and defected to
William but when James’ daughter Anne declared her support for William as well,
he lost his nerve and fled.
It was a feeble attempt at
escape and within days he was caught by local fisherman and returned to London.
Fortunately for James, William had no desire to make a martyr of his
father-in-law. He had what he wanted. Two days before Christmas, William
allowed James to escape the country and of course, he went straight to Louis in
France.
As William and Mary settled
themselves in, James was plotting his revenge. He wasn’t finished yet. Not by a
long shot.
But that’s another story.
Giveaway
*Giveaway is now closed.*
Giveaway Rules
Tweet this post with the hashtag #TrishaHughesGiveaway or leave a comment on the bottom of this post to be in with a chance to win a paperback copy of Viking to Virgin and Virgin to Victoria.
• Giveaway ends at 11:59pm BST on June 30th. You must be 18 or older to enter.
• Giveaway is open INTERNATIONALLY.
• Only one entry per household.
• All giveaway entrants agree to be honest and not cheat the systems; any suspect of fraud is decided upon by blog/site owner and the sponsor, and entrants may be disqualified at our discretion.
• Winner has 48 hours to claim prize or a new winner is chosen.
I was born in a little outback town called Blackall in Central Queensland, Australia. From there my parents moved to the Brisbane suburb of Fortitude Valley where I grew up to be a tiny, self-reliant little girl.
My first book, ‘Daughters of Nazareth’ is my story, written eighteen years ago, fuelled on by the discovery of a family I never knew I had. It’s full of family secrets, tremendous heartache but proves the human spirit’s amazing ability to triumph over adversity. Nineteen years ago, after just one phone call, my life changed abruptly. With that change came a passion for writing and I have been writing ever since.
I love writing crime novels but my passion is with the history of the British Monarchy. The first in my ‘V2V’trilogy is ‘Vikings to Virgin – The Hazards of being King’ published in 2017. The second in the series is due for release on 28th April this year and is called ‘Virgin to Victoria – The Queen is Dead. Long live the Queen.’ The final book, ‘Victoria to Vikings – The Circle of Blood’ will be released early 2019.
Virgin to Victoria
The Queen is Dead. Long live the Queen
After the death of Elizabeth I’s sister, ‘Bloody Mary’, England had high hopes for their new queen when she came to the throne. 25-year-old Elizabeth I attended her first council exuding an air of quiet confidence, even though she was inheriting a bankrupt nation torn apart by religious discord. It was chaotic.
Despite her amazing legacy and despite what her father, Henry VIII, had desired above all else, Elizabeth failed England in one vital point. She never married and did not leave an heir to the Tudor dynasty. By making that one fateful decision, she left the path open for the Stuarts in Scotland to take over and life would never be the same.
‘Virgin to Victoria’ travels in time through Elizabeth I’s amazing life, through the confusion of the Stuart dynasty, through the devastation of a Civil War led by Oliver Cromwell, through horrific battles for the throne and through the turbulent and discordant Hanover dynasty with its intricate family squabbles.
Queen Victoria did not ask to be Queen. It was thrust upon her by the accident of birth and then by a succession of accidents that removed all others who stood between her and the throne. She assumed it reluctantly and, at first, incompetently. Parliament was sure the 18-year-old could be relied upon to leave the job of running the country to the professionals.
Couldn’t she?
I loved this post. I adore the period which I studied and one day plan to write. Excellent article.
ReplyDeleteI think this is such a fascinating period in history. I always felt sorry for Monmouth, he had such a tragic end. On another note, I would love to win a copy of your book, it sounds amazing!!
ReplyDeleteSuper-clear summary of something I had always meant to read more about but had never got round to. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteExcellent post. I don't know nearly enough about the 1688 revolution, and even less about James II. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThe Giveaway is now closed. The winners are Carol McGrath ~ who commented on this post. And, DK Marley, who tweeted the hashtag on Twitter. Congratulations!!
ReplyDelete