By Catherine Hughes
Publication Date: January 19th, 2026
Publisher: Historium Press
Pages: 474
Genre: Historical Fiction
History books record the experiences of the powerful, the rich, the famous. Their voices dominate the pages, commanding us to accept their perspective as truth. But what if we could hear the whispers of those who were never given a chance to speak? How would this affect our understanding of the past?
Normandy, 1064
Celia Campion, a girl of humble background, finds herself caught in a web of intrigue when Duke William commands her to work as his spy, holding her younger sister hostage. Her mission: to sail across the sea to Wilton Abbey and convince Margaret, daughter of Edward the Exile, to take final vows rather than form a marriage alliance with the newly crowned king to the North, Malcolm III of Scotland. Preventing a union between the Saxons and Scots is critical to the success of the Duke’s plan to take England, and more importantly for Celia, it is the only way to keep her sister alive.
In this sweeping epic that spans the years before and after the Conquest, two women from opposite sides of the English Channel whisper across the chasm of time to tell their story of the tumultuous days that eventually changed the course of history. As they struggle to survive in a world marked by danger, loss, and betrayal, their lives intersect, and they soon come to realize they are both searching for the same thing--someone they can trust amidst the treachery that surrounds them.
Together, their voices form a narrative never before told.
With quiet authority and remarkable sensitivity, “Therein Lies the Pearl” draws the reader into a richly imagined world shaped by power, faith, and human frailty. At its heart, the novel stands out for its nuanced portrayal of women navigating perilous worlds and for its ability to render history through vivid, compassionate storytelling. From the opening chapters, it becomes clear that Catherine Hughes has created something rare: a narrative that not only recreates a pivotal moment in time, but also explores how ambition, devotion, and circumstance combine to shape individual destinies.
The opening scene upon the North Sea serves not as a beginning in the conventional sense, but as a carefully chosen frame for the story that follows. As the storm rages and Celia clings to the mast in defiance of both nature and fate, the reader is placed at a moment of reckoning — a point toward which an entire life has been moving. From here, the narrative turns back in time, unfolding the long chain of events, choices, loyalties, and betrayals that have carried her to this perilous crossing. What distinguishes this opening is not merely its drama, but its quiet promise: that the true story lies not in what will happen next, but in understanding how this moment came to be.
One of the great strengths of this novel lies in its portrayal of women navigating profoundly dangerous worlds. Celia’s life is shaped by hunger, flight, violence, and the ever-present threat of male authority. Her devotion to her sister Vivienne gives her purpose, yet also renders her constantly vulnerable. As she becomes entangled in the intrigues of Matilda’s court, it quickly becomes apparent that advancement here is no blessing. Favour is a form of currency, protection a form of control, and every kindness carries an unspoken price. The court scenes are especially effective, filled with quiet tension in which power is exercised not through force, but through smiles, gifts, and carefully chosen words.
Margaret’s story provides a beautifully judged counterpoint. Where Celia confronts visible dangers, Margaret faces subtler tyrannies — expectation, sanctity, surveillance, and the relentless pressure of dynastic ambition. Her faith is sincere and deeply moving, and her longing for a contemplative life is portrayed with great tenderness. The visions that intrude upon her prayers are among the most haunting passages in the novel. Hughes handles these moments with admirable restraint, allowing them to enrich rather than dominate the narrative. Particularly powerful are those scenes in which prophecy leaves its mark upon Margaret’s own body, blurring the boundary between spiritual calling and physical consequence.
The historical setting is rendered with exquisite care. Daily life — childbirth, illness, prayer, travel, hunger — unfolds naturally alongside great political events, grounding the narrative firmly in lived experience. The courts of Normandy and England are portrayed as places of splendour and danger in equal measure, where alliances shift swiftly and loyalty is always fragile. Hughes brings historical figures vividly to life, not as distant icons, but as complex, calculating, and often deeply flawed human beings.
Matilda emerges as a fascinating presence: intelligent, observant, and perpetually weighing the worth of those around her. Her patronage is both opportunity and threat, and the ambiguity of her power is beautifully conveyed. Duke William’s commanding presence is quietly ominous, but it is Harold Godwinson who casts the longest shadow. He is portrayed with chilling restraint, his entitlement and appetite lending every scene an undercurrent of menace. His very presence unsettles, and the novel never underestimates the fear he inspires.
Equally compelling is the treatment of love and loyalty. Celia’s bond with Simon is tender, hesitant, and painfully realistic. Their connection promises safety and companionship, yet obligation and fear render every hope fragile. Affection here is never free from consequence, and commitment always exacts a price. It is often in the quietest moments — a shared task, an unfinished question, a glance held too long — that the emotional power of the novel is most keenly felt.
What ultimately distinguishes “Therein Lies the Pearl” is its moral and emotional intelligence. This is not a tale of neatly arranged heroes and villains, but of people acting within constraints they did not choose. Power is shown not only in conquest, but in silence, in ownership, and in the ability to decide another’s future without their consent. Faith is presented not merely as comfort, but as struggle, doubt, and endurance. Ambition burns brightly throughout the narrative, yet always threatens to consume those who tend it.
As the novel draws towards its conclusion, the weight of approaching history becomes keenly felt — the crown unsettled, the realm trembling, destinies balanced upon a knife-edge. Yet Hughes never allows foreknowledge of events to overshadow the human stories at stake. Instead, she lingers in the uncertainty of the present, where every choice matters and every delay may prove fatal.
“Therein Lies the Pearl” is a novel of rare depth and distinction. It is absorbing without being indulgent, scholarly without stiffness, romantic without illusion. Above all, it is compassionate towards its women, its exiles, its doubters, and its survivors. For readers who cherish historical fiction rich in atmosphere, emotional complexity, and moral insight, this is a remarkable and deeply rewarding read.
Review by Mary Anne Yarde
Yarde Book Promotions
Pick up your copy of
Therein Lies the Pearl
Catherine Hughes
Award winning writer, Catherine Hughes is a first-time author who, from her earliest years, immersed herself in reading. Historical fiction is her genre of choice, and her bookshelves are stocked with selections from ancient, Medieval, and Renaissance Europe as well as those involving New England settlements and pioneer life in America. After double-majoring in English and business management on the undergraduate level, Catherine completed her Master's degree in British literature at Drew University and then entered the classroom where she has been teaching American, British, and World Literature at the high school level for the last thirty years.
Aside from teaching and reading, Catherine can often be found outdoors, drawing beauty and inspiration from the world of nature. Taking the words of Thoreau to heart, "It is the marriage of the soul with nature that makes the intellect fruitful," Catherine sets aside time every day to lace up her sneakers and run with her dog in pre-dawn or late afternoon hours on the beaches of Long Island. When her furry companion isn't busy chasing seagulls or digging up remnants of dead fish, she soaks in the tranquility of the ocean setting, freeing her mind to tap into its deepest recesses where creativity and imagination preside.
In Silence Cries the Heart, Hughes’s first book, received the Gold Medal in Romance for the Feathered Quill 2024 Book of the Year contest, the Gold Medal for Fiction in the 2024 Literary Titan competition, and the 2024 International Impact Book Award for Historical Fiction. In addition, the Historical Fiction Company gave it a five star rating and a Silver Medal in the category of Historical Fiction Romance. The book was also featured in the February 2024 Issue 31 of the Historical Times magazine and was listed as one of the Best Historical Fiction Books of 2024 by the History Bards Podcast. Therein Lies the Pearl is her second venture into the world of historical fiction.
Connect with Catherine Hughes:
%20copy.png)
.png)
