Today, I am chatting with Amber Hoyem about Strawberry Moon, the first novel in her Light and Shadow Series.
Set in seventeenth-century Massachusetts, the novel follows Sarah and John, two people living on the margins of a society in which identity, faith and social standing can determine the course of a life. Sarah's Massachusett heritage and John's position as an indentured servant place them outside many of the structures governing the world around them, while their growing relationship offers the possibility of something neither expected. Pasted markdown
Amber joins me today to talk about bringing Sarah and John to life, exploring the complexities of belonging and identity, and placing an intimate love story against the turbulent realities of early colonial Massachusetts.
But first, let's check out Strawberry Moon
Publication Date: 5th June 2026
Publisher: Independently Published
Print Length: 335 Pages
Genre: Historical Fiction
Inspired by the author’s ancestral connection to John and Sarah Whipple, Strawberry Moon is a literary historical romance set in 1630s Massachusetts, where a forbidden slow‑burn love grows in the shadow of cultural upheaval.
Massachusetts Bay, 1630: When Puritan soldiers destroy Merrymount, Sarah watches her English father dragged away in chains and loses the only home where she ever felt she belonged. Forced back to her mother’s Massachusett kin, she finds herself caught between two worlds—and fully accepted by neither.
John Whipple arrives as an indentured servant determined to earn his freedom. Sarah never expects to find an ally in him, much less a love that could cost them everything. But as Puritan rule tightens and fear spreads, their connection becomes increasingly dangerous.
With war looming and loyalties hardening, Sarah must decide what she is willing to sacrifice to protect her people—and who she dares to become in a colony determined to divide her.
Atmospheric, intimate, and rooted in early American history, Strawberry Moon blends Indigenous resilience, cultural conflict, and a tender forbidden romance into one unforgettable story.
Strawberry Moon places Sarah between two identities—Sarah in the English world and Kimi in her mother's Massachusett community. What first inspired you to create a heroine who belongs to both worlds yet is never entirely accepted by either?
One of the things that fascinated me most in my research was the silence surrounding Merrymount’s children. There had to be children born of those unions; Morton himself mentions marriages. So where did those children go? How were they absorbed or not absorbed into the surrounding communities? Those questions became puzzle pieces.
Sarah grew out of that curiosity. If she were of mixed heritage, it could explain why her maiden name never appears in the records, why she was referred to simply as “Goodwife,” why her first child's baptism was delayed two years, and why she wasn’t welcomed into the church until 1641. She was only admitted once the church opened membership to African and Native enslaved people, which further suggested she occupied a liminal place in the community. It might also shed light on why her home in Providence was left standing when others were burned during King Philip’s War. All these puzzle pieces were coming together for me.
What began as a historical question, “what happened to the children of Merrymount,” became a character.
Sarah and John begin the novel from very different circumstances, but neither has much control over the life being imposed upon them. What interested you about bringing these two characters together?
The historical records are clear that John was indentured and living on the outskirts of Dorchester, and someone in his social position would have had very few choices when it came to marriage or shaping his own future. If Sarah were of mixed heritage, she would understand what it meant to be seen as other, to be pushed to the margins of a community. That shared experience of being outside the structures that defined early colonial life is what interested me. I imagined that recognition between them creating a quiet but powerful bond.
John arrives in Massachusetts as an indentured servant, with survival rather than opportunity defining his early experience of the colony. Why was it important to show seventeenth-century New England through the eyes of someone without wealth or social standing?
I believe there are too few stories from this period that look closely at the people without wealth or social standing. Most narratives about seventeenth century New England focus on ministers, magistrates, or landowners, but the colony was built just as much by indentured servants, laborers, and families living on the margins. I wanted to understand what life looked like for someone like John, whose choices were limited from the moment he arrived and whose survival depended on the whims of others.
Seeing the colony through his eyes allowed me to show a version of New England that was harsher, more precarious, and far less romantic than the one preserved in official records. It also made his connection with Sarah more meaningful, because both navigate a world where their place is never guaranteed.
The relationship between Sarah and John develops slowly through moments of care and intimacy rather than sweeping romantic gestures. How did you approach creating that gradual connection between them?
I approached their connection with the realities of the period firmly in mind. In my research, I found many accounts of secret relationships, unmarried mothers, and the harsh consequences faced by servants who crossed social or cultural boundaries. Within that world, a sweeping and overt romance simply would not have been possible for two people in Sarah and John’s positions.
Their relationship had to grow in the quiet spaces available to them: small acts of care, shared labor, stolen conversations, and moments of intimacy that accumulate over time. Those subtle exchanges allowed their bond to deepen gradually, shaped as much by the constraints around them as by their own choices. The slow build also let me show how their connection strengthens through hardship and is continually threatened by circumstance, culture, and the fragile standing they each hold. It is a love that survives because it grows carefully, deliberately, and in the shadows where it can exist at all.
Belonging is one of the strongest themes in the novel. Sarah is continually confronted by other people's ideas about who she should be. What did you want to explore through her struggle between inherited identity and the identity she chooses for herself?
Sarah’s struggle between inherited identity and the identity she chooses for herself grew out of the questions that stayed with me throughout my research. I kept returning to the history of the Massachusett people and the ways colonization reshaped every part of their world. I wondered what happened to families who were fractured by disease and displacement, and how individuals navigated the pressure to assimilate in order to survive. Someone like Sarah would have lived at the intersection of those forces, carrying traditions and kinship ties that were increasingly difficult to maintain while also being pulled into English systems that demanded conformity.
Through her story, I wanted to explore what it means to inherit a cultural identity that is threatened by erasure, and what it costs to hold onto it when every external structure insists on something different. I was also interested in the agency she carves out for herself. Even within severe constraints, she makes choices about who she will be, what she will protect, and which parts of her heritage she refuses to relinquish. Her struggle allowed me to examine belonging as something shaped by history and community, but also by personal conviction. It is not a simple conflict between two worlds. It is the ongoing work of preserving a self that is continually challenged, constrained, and reshaped by the forces around her.
Smallpox, a hurricane, and eventually the Pequot War all shape the characters' lives. How did you balance these major historical events with the quieter, more intimate story unfolding between Sarah and John?
I treated the major historical events as the spine of the narrative, the structure that shapes the world Sarah and John must move through. The smallpox epidemic, the hurricane, and the Pequot War were all defining forces in seventeenth century Massachusetts, and I wanted the story to acknowledge their weight without letting them overshadow the quieter human experiences at the center of the novel. My approach was to imagine what daily life would feel like inside those moments. People still worked, cared for one another, and formed relationships even as history pressed in around them.
The intimacy between Sarah and John grows in the spaces that remain when the world is unstable. Their connection is not separate from these events. It is shaped by them, but it is not consumed by them. By keeping the historical record present as atmosphere and pressure rather than constant spectacle, I could let the love story remain central. Life continues while history unfolds, and I wanted their relationship to reflect that truth.
The novel doesn't present colonial Massachusetts simply as a place of new beginnings; it is also a world of fear, violence, strict social expectations, and competing loyalties. How important was it to challenge some of the more familiar ideas about early colonial life?
It was very important to challenge the familiar, simplified ideas about early colonial Massachusetts. “The City Upon a Hill” speech by Massachusetts Bay Colony Governor John Winthrop is widely taught and often presented as the defining vision of the colony. It is idealistic, righteous, and entirely one sided. When I read Winthrop’s journals, I saw a very different picture. The entries reveal smallpox outbreaks, political dissidents, territory disputes, war, and the beginnings of genocide. They show a community struggling with fear, instability, and internal conflict rather than a unified moral project.
What frustrated me most was how the Massachusett people are never mentioned in the history books. An entire population is ignored or reduced to a footnote, which amounts to erasure. The same is true for places like Merrymount, which is often omitted because it does not fit the familiar narrative of Puritan order and purpose.
I wanted the novel to reflect the full reality of the period. Colonial Massachusetts was not only a place of new beginnings. It was a world shaped by violence, strict social expectations, competing loyalties, and the consequences of colonization. By bringing those elements forward, I hoped to complicate the traditional story and make space for the people and experiences that were pushed aside in the historical record.
Sarah's connection to her Massachusett heritage gives the novel a perspective not always foregrounded in fiction about seventeenth-century New England. What considerations were most important to you when developing this aspect of her character and world?
I wanted the world Sarah inhabits to feel fully alive. The flora, the fauna, the seasonal rhythms, the traditions, and the social complexities were all essential to building a Massachusett perspective that is often missing from fiction about seventeenth century New England. My goal was to bring the lives of the Massachusett people to the forefront. They were present, they had been present for generations, and they continued to exist throughout colonization, even as their world was reshaped around them.
It was important to show the differences in culture and worldview, not as background decoration but as a lived reality that shaped Sarah’s identity. The Neponset River became a natural symbol of that divide. It marked a boundary between two communities, but it also represented the space where Sarah’s inherited identity and her lived experience met and sometimes collided.
By grounding her character in these details, I hoped to honor the Massachusett people and give readers a perspective that reflects the depth and continuity of their world.
Strawberry Moon is the first novel in the Light and Shadow Series. How much of the wider story did you know when you began writing Sarah and John's journey?
Through my ancestral research, I already knew the wider story before I began writing Strawberry Moon. The Light and Shadow Series grew out of that work. I understood the historical and religious pressures that shaped colonial New England and how those forces would influence the Whipple generations that follow. Their lives unfold within a much larger narrative that I had already traced, which made it possible to focus this first novel on the earliest part of their journey while knowing the broader world their story grows into.
For readers reaching the end of Strawberry Moon, what do you hope stays with them most strongly about Sarah and John's story?
I hope readers carry with them the sense of a powerful love story, one that is achingly beautiful and deeply human. Sarah and John build a life outside the expectations of their time, on the outskirts of society, navigating a world that is changing around them. What matters most to me is the way they hold on to identity, humanity, trust, and the courage to love despite the uncertainty. Their story is about choosing one another in a world that does